That Skinny Chick Can Bake
Mushroom Topped Pepper Steak Featured image

Mushroom Topped Pepper Steak for Two

Home » Entree Recipes » Mushroom Topped Pepper Steak for Two Jump To Recipe

Does your Valentine love beef? Then this simple, elegant recipe for Mushroom Topped Pepper Steak for Two is the perfect entree for your Valentine’s Day celebration.Mushroom Topped Pepper Steak topped with mushrooms on a white plate with asparagus spears

Mushroom Topped Pepper Steak for Two

Early February isn’t exactly grilling weather in Indiana. Yet, I feel somewhat obligated to make a fabulous steak dinner for Valentine’s Day. With only 3 of us at home, and one who rarely eats meat, a big rare roast beef was out. I turned to Dorie Greenspan’s stove top cooked Bistrot Paul Bert Pepper Steak and added a few twists. The results were nothing short of phenomenal! Just look at that perfectly cooked rare beef. Bill says he likes it “Just short of mooing.”

Mushroom Topped Pepper Steak sliced on a white dinner plate

Tips for Making These Mushroom Topped Pepper Steaks

Two steaks coated with coarsely ground peppercorns, sauteed in a cast iron skillet, then topped with mushrooms and a creamy Cognac sauce made for a fabulous celebratory entree.

  • I dry brined the steaks by sprinkling them with kosher salt then parking them in the refrigerator, uncovered, overnight.
  • This process helps infuse some salt into the meat for deeper seasoning, tenderized and helped dry the surface for better browning.  It’s definitely worth the couple minutes it takes to do this extra step.
  • I also added sauteed mushrooms to the mix. Mushrooms and beef provide the savory taste, umami due to the glutamates in each ingredient. Meaty mushrooms, tender steak and a luscious cream sauce make for one unforgettable dinner!
  • PRO-Tip: Use a meat thermometer to cook your steaks to the perfect temperature for your taste buds. Nothing worse than an overcooked, expensive piece of top notch beef!

How to Check Your Beef to See if It’s Done

Different cuts and thicknesses of beef and different cooking methods need different cooking times. Some seasoned chefs can tell by using a finger to press down on the beef if it’s rare, medium, etc. I like to rely on an instant read thermometer.

  • Insert your thermometer into the center of the steak, away from any bone.
  • PRO-Tip: You will want to pull your steak off the heat when it’s 5 degrees below your desired temperature as it will continue to have some carryover cooking time.
  • PRO-Tip: Cover the meat with foil as it rests for about 10 minutes before serving. This allows the juices to reincorporate and the beef temperature to rise another 5 degrees.
  • Rare beef should be cooked to 125 degrees (pull off at 120º) for a cool red center, medium rare cooked to 135º for a warm red center, medium to 145º for a warm pink center, medium well to 150º for a slightly pink center and well to 160º with little to no pink center.*
Mushroom Topped Pepper Steak sliced on a white dinner plate

More Easy Dinner Recipes for Two

With Valentine’s Day just around the corner, it’s the perfect time to start planning a romantic dinner for two. An intimate dinner at home is much more appealing than a crowded, overpriced restaurant.

Chicken Marsala for Two is an elegant alternative to beef as is this tasty Balsamic Glazed Salmon. Consider serving this Kahlua Tiramisu for Two for dessert or this Classic Creme Brulee.

*Cooking temperatures courtesy of Certified Angus Beef

Print

Love this recipe? Please consider rating it in the comments below. You can also follow me on Facebook, Pinterest and Instagram.

Mushroom Topped Pepper Steak for Two

Perfectly made pepper steak cooked on the stove top and served with sauteed mushrooms and a Cognac cream sauce!

  • Author: Liz Berg
  • Prep Time: 20 mins
  • Cook Time: 20 minutes
  • Total Time: 40 minutes
  • Yield: 2 servings 1x
  • Category: Beef, Entree
  • Method: Sauteing
  • Cuisine: American

Ingredients

  • 2 filet mignon steaks (beef tenderloin), 2 inches thick*
  • Kosher salt

Mushrooms::

  • 8 ounces mushrooms, sliced or cut in half
  • 2 tablespoons butter
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt, or to taste
  • 1/8 teaspoon finely ground black pepper
  • 1/4 teaspoon fresh thyme leaves
  • 2 tablespoons white wine

To make steaks::

  • 1 tablespoon vegetable oil
  • 1/2 tablespoon butter
  • 1/4 cup Cognac
  • 1/2 cup cream
  • Kosher salt, to taste (I used a pinch)
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons coarsely ground black pepper

Instructions

  1. The night before, season the filets with kosher salt and leave them uncovered in the refrigerator.
  2. An hour before cooking, remove the meat from the refrigerator and allow to come to room temperature. Make the mushrooms. Melt the butter in a skillet, add mushrooms, then season with salt, pepper and thyme. Cook until soft, then add white wine and cook until the wine evaporates. Remove from pan and set aside.
  3. To make steaks, add oil and butter to the saucepan (I use a cast iron pan).Heat pan to medium-high. Sprinkle steaks with coarse pepper and gently press into meat. Add steaks and cook 3 minutes or more per side until internal temperature reaches desired doneness (I remove at 120º for very rare). Remove from pan and cover loosely with foil.
  4. To make sauce, pour off excess oil, add Cognac to pan and allow to reduce over medium heat. Add cream and cook for a couple minutes. Taste the sauce and add a pinch of salt if desired.
  5. To serve, place a steak on each plate, mound with mushrooms and drizzle with the Cognac cream sauce.

Notes

There is enough sauce to serve 4 if you’d like to serve more guests.
*I recommend Certified Angus Beef tenderloin.

 

 

Note: This post may contain affiliate links; view my Disclosure Policy for details. I earn a small percentage from any purchase you make by clicking on these links at no extra cost to you.

26 comments on “Mushroom Topped Pepper Steak for Two”

  1. That’s a dream meal for any beef lover!

  2. I was planning our traditional pot of Chili for the Super Bowl today… Now you have me thinking about the steak in the freezer:@)

  3. what a fabulous meal!

  4. Yum! What time is dinner! This looks wonderful and perfectly cooked!

  5. A perfect steak dinner, Liz! better than you would get in many restaurants!

  6. Sounds like a delicious sauce, and I always like mushrooms for a steak topping!

  7. This would be much loved in our house!

  8. This is gorgeous! Steve loves steak and will be so happy when I make him this dish!!!!

  9. Oooh, perfectly cooked filets! My husband just passed behind me and saw your photo. I think this will be his next dinner request 🙂

  10. I have a similar recipe that we used to make all the time that we loved! Will have to revisit it perhaps for V-day!

  11. You cooked that filet to perfection! I never grill, even in nice weather. I have two stainless steel all clad skillets that do all the heavy lifting – steak, fritattas, fish – everything.

  12. Your steak is perfectly cooked. I started salivating the moment I saw the photo.

  13. This looks picture perfect and ideal for our Sunday night dinner!

  14. LOL. You and Bill are very special people indeed….I’m on the same page as your husband when it comes to sweets…But just short of mooing…Mmm, a little different. Anyway, looks like you’ve got the perfect present for your beloved…P.s. Read your reply on Pies and Plots and am so inspired by your good heart <3 (And always your gourmet made easy recipes!)

  15. Mmmm … that looks so good! A perfect dinner for 2 for Valentine’s Day, or any other day.

  16. Looks beautiful and sure that sauce is wonderful.

  17. This is the perfect Valentine’s meal, Liz! Love that mushroom topping!

  18. This is just faboulous Liz! I think my love will love this recipe.

  19. Oh yum! Do you mind making a room for 1 more person? I promise to bring wine 🙂 And mushrooms? You really read your mind.

  20. Your steaks are absolute perfection, Liz! But you really got me with the Cognac cream sauce. Swooning over here!

  21. Deelicious!! Mushrooms make it even better. Looks good, Liz.

  22. Great minds! Our recipes this week are similar, yet different! I always feel you can never go wrong with a good steak with some sort of boozy sauce for a special dinner!

  23. You certainly know how to cook a beautiful steak! Love the mushrooms as a complementary topping.

  24. Fantastic idea Liz! The Cognac cream sounds fantastic! Now we get why you didn’t use the mushrooms for Madeira;) Exceptional dish, bravo!

  25. Dear hubby loves his steak cooked this way and I would certainly earn brownie points for this one!

  26. Pingback: Rack of Lamb with Strawberry Mint Glaze #SundaySupper - Sunday Supper Movement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.